Skip to main content

What Makes An #Editor publish a Short Story in a #Literary #Magazine?

By 09/01/2014May 28th, 2019Interview, writer, writing, writing advice
A Character's Writer's Block?

Publishing Stories in a Literary Magazine

As part of my ongoing guest post series in this blog,  Suchen Christine Lim, one of Singapore’s best known authors, spoke to us about her writing journey  before the holidays. Today, Scott Bryson, the editor of Cigale Literary Magazine answers questions on what leads him to choose a short story for his publication.  Feel free to leave your questions for him in the comments section, and he might stop by to answer them.


1.      What led you to establish Cigale Literary magazine? What are your plans for its future?

I hoped to connect readers with new and emerging writers and to help those
writers begin a career in the literary arts. I saw a need for a publication that emphasized literature as a tradition, where writers who are also avid readers could contribute to a literary conversation. In the future I hope to publish translations and maybe poetry. I also hope to go to print and pay my authors.

2.      What do you look for in a story you accept for publication?
I look for good writing and an interesting tale. I like works that expand my perspectives on humanity and look out to a wider world.
3.      What would you like to see more of in the submissions to your magazine, and what would you like to see less of?

I would like to see more writing that is challenging and shows an urgency
in speaking about universal human themes. I would also like to see more
writing from a third person narrative and some that is genre bending.
I would like to see less writing told from the first person and less that
is the author’s personal history, unless that personal history reveals
some wider truth about the human experience.

4.  To a lot of readers, literary fiction is boring writing. How can
writers engage more readers with their literary work?

Literary fiction is meant to provide perspective and challenge the reader.
It is meant to be difficult. But the more you read it the more enjoyable
it becomes.

5. What tips would you give unpublished writers who are trying to get their first story published in a magazine?
  • Keep polishing your work, as it might not be ready when you first finish it.
  • Make sure you follow the submission instructions from the magazine.
  • Have a general understanding of the magazine and what they usually look for. Even magazines that say they don’t look for anything in particular have something in mind.
  • Read, read, and read.
  • But mostly, getting published is luck.
6.      Name 5 short stories that are your absolute favorite.

1. The Spider Thread – Ryunosuke Akutagawa
2. Poor People – Fydor Dostoyevsky
3. A Hunger Artist – Franz Kafka
4. The Fruit at the Bottom of the Bowl – Ray Bradbury
5. Frost and Fire – Ray Bradbury

7.      What was the last book/ short story you read? Would you recommend it to my readers, and why or why not?

I recently finished A Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess. Yes I would
recommend this to your readers as a classic of English Literature. In many
ways it is like some short stories I receive but Burgess makes a larger
point than showing the reader violent acts of a youth.

Cigale Literary Magazine

Cigale Literary Magazine was founded in September 2011 as an online literary magazine to publish the works of new and existing authors. It is a quarterly online literary journal featuring powerful new voices in the genres of short fiction, flash fiction fiction, and literary criticism/reviews.


Have you sent you stories for publication in a journal or magazine? What has been your experience of publication? Do you have story submission questions for Scott?

Damyanti Biswas

Damyanti Biswas is the author of You Beneath Your Skin and numerous short stories that have been published in magazines and anthologies in the US, the UK, and Asia. She has been shortlisted for Best Small Fictions and Bath Novel Awards and is co-editor of the Forge Literary Magazine. Her next literary crime thriller, The Blue Bar, is represented by Lucienne Diver from The Knight Agency, and was published by Thomas & Mercer on January 1, 2023.

I appreciate comments, and I always visit back. If you're having trouble commenting, let me know via the contact form, or tweet me up @damyantig !

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


  • seanbidd says:

    I’ll have to dig through some of the short stories churned out, and check the frame of reference used. Most are third person, but there’s the odd few in first person, due in main to the recounting of the story’s fiction by a character involved, or at the start I may not of resolved identities for certain characters.

    The conversation in the post above has come along at a good time, as I’m in the middle of revisiting a bunch of rough drafts to rework. Thank you.

  • techzealo says:

    @damyanti thnx for the like and subscription, we really appreciate it, especially since we’re just starting out and working hard to make a name for ourselves in the blogging world. If anyone else wants to check us out, come over to 😀

  • Reblogged this on Donald Baker – author and commented:
    Interesting article.

  • Really informative.
    There are lots of e-zines out there, and each has its own “flavour”
    Thanks for sharing this.

    • Damyanti says:

      Michelle, you’re welcome, and completely agree with you about each magazine having its different flavor.

  • Great interview. I thinks it’s also helpful to hear from editors to find out what exactly they are looking for. I also loved your comment about literary fiction. I find it hard to read at times, especially in magazines. Probably because I don’t write literary fiction, though I LOVE Toni Morrison’s works. I have one flash fiction piece that was accepted for publication for March 2014. My first! Hopefully, I’ll be able to get the others accepted somewhere, too.

  • I read 400 submissions last fall for a university-based literary journal. So many of the stories lack true conflict or character motivation. I think that’s the hardest part about literary fiction–the balance between matters of craft and also telling an engaging story.

    • Damyanti says:

      I agree. Literary fiction tends to focus on character but sometimes its writers forget all about character motivation, an aspect which, imho, shows us more about the character than anythings else.

  • shanbarnacle says:

    Thanks for this interview! It is always helpful to know more about the people who will be reading (and essentially judging) our work. I wish more editors would list their favorite short stories. At least this one has decent (yet masculine) taste!

    • Damyanti says:

      I suppose favorites change from time to time, so it might be hard for editors to list theirs on their sites. But I agree it would be nice to know– I submitted my story to Scott and got accepted with no idea of what he likes.

  • Informative post..Thanks and reblogged

  • Reblogged this on Veronica Haidar and commented:
    Useful tips for short story writers

  • Thanks for this – really interesting, enlightening and useful. Will definitely look out for Cigale Literary Magazine in the future.

  • jakewitcher says:

    ” I would also like to see more writing from a third person narrative and some that is genre bending. I would like to see less writing told from the first person and less that is the author’s personal history, unless that personal history reveals some wider truth about the human experience.”

    This really resonates with me and is also something I have trouble with sometimes! I’m definitely going to work on this.

    • Damyanti says:

      Jake, i thought it would be useful to get an editors perspective of a magazine– each editor has different tastes, and it pays to know about as many of them as we can 🙂

  • jakewitcher says:

    Reblogged this on the witcherer.

  • thanks for sharing his views. i have not read a single one of his favorite stories though…:(

    • Damyanti says:

      Sharmishta, all of them are worth a read, especially the one by Kafka. There’s a free Guardian podcast of Mohsin Hamid reading it, and it is excellent.

  • This is a very interesting interview with some wonderful advice. Thanks!

  • orionwriter says:

    I submitted a short story to an online magazine back in November. I never found it if it was published or not (so I assume that it wasn’t) but it was a lot of fun working on the story. I had never attempted to have something published before, so it was a great learning experience. Honestly, I’d do it again. It was an excellent learning experience and I highly recommend it to anyone looking to be published.
    I also liked that Scott included in his tips, “Read, read, and read.” That is my absolute favourite tip.
    This was a great post!
    Thanks for sharing.

    • Damyanti says:

      Glad that you liked this post. Getting something published is also about not giving up. Writers rarely receive acceptances, it is mostly rejections– the whole idea is to fail better till you succeed.

  • Tonia says:

    Excellent share. Thank you!

  • Reblogged this on A Blog by That Guy and commented:
    While I recently wrote about how on Google Plus users need to have engagement with other users around the social media website. Part of that engagement is sharing other’s content that you think is interesting, inviting, cool, or just plain kickass.

    In this case, this post crafted by Daily (w)rite is in the kickass category. For those writers out there looking to get their feet wet in writing, check out what she has to share regarding the Cigale Literary Magazine.

  • Obed Medina says:

    Reblogged this on A Life in Words.

  • A very interesting and informative interview, thanks…

%d bloggers like this: